Dr David Lowry

Wednesday, 12 April 2017

Why it is just so darned hard to establish the provenance of truth over chemical weapons use in Syria?


The text below  is extracted from a front page New York Times story, on 12 April 2017
At the Kremlin on Tuesday, Mr. Putin spoke emphatically against the American accusations, saying he would request a formal examination by the United Nations and the international community and trying to cast doubt on the Trump administration’s conclusions. Mr. Putin compared the White House’s arguments to the erroneous intelligence findings on weapons of mass destruction that drew the United States into war with Iraq in 2003.

“To my mind, this strongly resembles what happened in 2003 when representatives of the United States showed in the Security Council what was supposed to be chemical weapons found in Iraq,” Mr. Putin said after a meeting with President Sergio Mattarella of Italy. Using an acronym for the Islamic State, he added, “A military campaign in Iraq ensued, and it ended in devastation of the country, growth of the terror threat and emergence of ISIL on the international scene.”

On Tuesday, Mr. Putin repeated his claim that opposition forces had essentially tried to frame the Syrian government by placing chemical weapons in civilian areas and blaming Mr. Assad’s forces.



“We have information from various sources that similar provocations — and I have no other word for that — are being prepared in other regions of Syria, including southern suburbs of Damascus, where they intend to plant certain substance again and accuse official Syrian authorities of using it,” Mr. Putin said.

White House officials also said American intelligence agencies did not believe that the Islamic State or other terrorist groups had sarin gas.

(extract from : “White House Accuses Russia of Cover-Up in Syria Chemical Attack; By JULIE HIRSCHFELD DAVIS and HELENE COOPER, NYTimes, APRIL 12, 2017; https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/11/world/middleeast/russia-syria-chemical-weapons-white-house.html)

 

The Moscow Times meantime reported  on April 11, from the Kremlin Press Service,

“Vladimir Putin rejected allegations that the Syrian government recently used chemical weapons to kill more than 70 civilians in the province of Idlib, and said the White House’s military response resembles the events of 2003, when the U.S. invaded Iraq on unfounded claims that Saddam Hussein possessed weapons of mass destruction.

Putin also warned that anti-government forces in Syria are preparing “provocations” using chemical weapons, intending to blame Damascus, in order to invite more U.S. airstrikes against government targets. The Russian president said these false-flag operations are being planned in Damascus and other areas across the country.

“We have information from different sources that similar provocations — this is the only word for it — are being prepared in different regions of Syria, including in the southern suburbs of Damascus, where they’re planning to spread some kind of substance and blame Syrian officials

(Source: Putin Says Syrian Rebels Plan to Frame Assad for Future Chemical Weapons Attacks;  https://themoscowtimes.com/news/putin-says-syrian-rebels-plan-to-frame-assad-for-future-chemical-weapons-attacks-57695

 

Backstory:

 

A New York Times investigation (https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/10/14/world/middleeast/us-casualties-of-iraq-chemical-weapons.html) published in October 2014found that the military had recovered thousands of old chemical warheads and shells in Iraq and that Americans and Iraqis had been wounded by them, but the government kept much of this information secret, from the public and troops alike.

These munitions were remnants of an Iraqi special weapons program that was abandoned long before the 2003 invasion, and they turned up sporadically during the American occupation in buried caches, as part of improvised bombs or on black markets.

See: American Firms’ Supplying Iraq’s Chemical Weapons Production

Analysis by Jonathan Tucker, who researched Saddam Hussein’s weapons programs, detailing delivery of American-made precursors for Iraq’s sulfur mustard agent. NewYork Times,  OCT.14, 2014 (https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/10/14/world/middleeast/american-firms-supplying-iraqs-chemical-weapons-production.html)

 
NYTimes.com no longer supports Internet Explorer 9 or earlier. Please upgrade your browser. LEARN MORE »
Declassified U.S. Report on Chemical Weapons Attack

The White House released a declassified four-page report that details United States intelligence on the chemical weapons attack, asserting that the Syrian and Russian governments have sought to confuse the world community about the assault through disinformation and “false narratives.”
APRIL 11, 2017
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/04/11/world/middleeast/document-Syria-Chemical-Weapons-Report-White-House.html?_r=0

NYTimes.com no longer supports Internet Explorer 9 or earlier. Please upgrade your browser. LEARN MORE »
                                      





 






     


    •  


      •  


        •  


          •  


            •  


              •  


                •  


                  •  


                    •  


                      •  


                        •  



















































































                              • Edit Profile
                              • My Account
                              • My Billing Information
                              • My Saved Items

                              • Africa
                              • Americas
                              • Asia
                              • Australia
                              • Europe
                              • Middle East
                              • At War
                              • Sinosphere

                              • Education
                              • The Upshot

                              • First Draft
                              • Elections
                              • The Upshot

                              • Events

                              • DealBook
                              • Economy
                              • Energy
                              • Markets
                              • Media
                              • Entrepreneurship
                              • Your Money
                              • Automobiles

                              • DealBook
                              • Economy
                              • Energy
                              • Markets
                              • Media
                              • Entrepreneurship
                              • Your Money
                              • Automobiles

                              • Op-Ed Columnists
                              • Editorials
                              • Contributing Writers
                              • Op-Ed Contributors
                              • Opinionator
                              • Letters
                              • Sunday Review
                              • Taking Note
                              • Room for Debate
                              • Public Editor

                              • Op-Ed Columnists
                              • Editorials
                              • Contributing Writers
                              • Op-Ed Contributors
                              • Opinionator
                              • Letters
                              • Sunday Review
                              • Taking Note
                              • Room for Debate
                              • Public Editor

                              • Bits
                              • Personal Tech

                              • Environment
                              • Space & Cosmos

                              • Well
                              • Money & Policy
                              • Health Guide

                              • Baseball
                              • Basketball: College
                              • Basketball: N.B.A.
                              • Football: College
                              • Football: N.F.L.
                              • Golf
                              • Hockey
                              • Soccer
                              • Tennis

                              • Baseball
                              • Basketball: College
                              • Basketball: N.B.A.
                              • Football: College
                              • Football: N.F.L.
                              • Golf
                              • Hockey
                              • Soccer
                              • Tennis

                              • Art & Design
                              • Books
                              • Dance
                              • Movies
                              • Music
                              • N.Y.C. Events Guide
                              • Television
                              • Theater
                              • Watching

                              • Art & Design
                              • Books
                              • Dance
                              • Movies
                              • Music
                              • N.Y.C. Events Guide
                              • Television
                              • Theater
                              • Watching

                              • Men's Style
                              • On the Runway
                              • Weddings

                              • Men's Style
                              • On the Runway
                              • Weddings

                              • Cooking
                              • Restaurant Search

                              • Cooking
                              • Restaurant Search

                              • The High End
                              • Commercial
                              • iPhone App
                              • Find A Home
                              • My Real Estate
                              • List Your Home

                              • U.S. & Politics
                              • International
                              • N.Y.
                              • Op-Docs
                              • Opinion
                              • Times Documentaries
                              • Business
                              • Tech
                              • Culture
                              • Style
                              • T Magazine
                              • Health
                              • Food
                              • Travel
                              • Sports
                              • Real Estate
                              • Science

                              • Women in the World
                              • New Work Summit
                              • Art for Tomorrow
                              • Higher Ed Leaders Forum
                              • Cities for Tomorrow
                              • Athens Democracy Forum
                              • Luxury Travel Conference
                              • Energy for Tomorrow
                              • DealBook Conference

                              • Home Page
                              • Home Page
                              • World
                              • U.S.
                              • Politics
                              • N.Y.
                              • Business
                              • Business
                              • Opinion
                              • Opinion
                              • Tech
                              • Science
                              • Health
                              • Sports
                              • Sports
                              • Arts
                              • Arts
                              • Fashion & Style
                              • Fashion & Style
                              • Food
                              • Food
                              • Travel
                              • Magazine
                              • T Magazine
                              • Real Estate
                              • Obituaries
                              • Video
                              • The Upshot
                              • Conferences
                              • Crossword
                              • Times Insider
                              • The Learning Network
                              • Multimedia
                              • Photography
                              • Podcasts
                              • NYT Store
                              • NYT Wine Club
                              • nytEducation
                              • Times Journeys
                              • Meal Kits
                              • Subscribe
                              • Manage Account
                              • Today's Paper
                              • Blogs
                              • Times Topics
                              • Tools & Services
                              • Jobs
                              • Classifieds
                              • Corrections
                              • Charles M. Blow
                              • David Brooks
                              • Frank Bruni
                              • Roger Cohen
                              • Gail Collins
                              • Ross Douthat
                              • Maureen Dowd
                              • Thomas L. Friedman
                              • Nicholas Kristof
                              • Paul Krugman
                              • Joe Nocera
                              • Charles M. Blow
                              • David Brooks
                              • Frank Bruni
                              • Roger Cohen
                              • Gail Collins
                              • Ross Douthat
                              • Maureen Dowd
                              • Thomas L. Friedman
                              • Nicholas Kristof
                              • Paul Krugman
                              • Joe Nocera

                              Edit Profile

                              Your profile is public. It will appear with any comments you leave on NYTimes.com


                              Edition
                              • English
                              • 中文 (Chinese)
                              • Español
                              Help
                              • FAQ
                              • Contact Us
                              Type Size
                              • A Type size small
                              • A Type size medium
                              • A Type size large

                              Log in

                              To save articles or get newsletters, alerts or recommendations – all free.


                              OR
                              Forgot password?
                              Terms of Service Privacy Policy
                              Don’t have an account? Sign Up

                              Sign up

                              To save articles or get newsletters, alerts or recommendations – all free.


                              OR



                              By signing up, you agree to receive updates and special offers for The New York Times’s products and services. You may unsubscribe at any time.
                              Terms of Service Privacy Policy
                              Already have an account? Log In


                              Posted by drdavidlowry at 03:36
                              Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest

                              No comments:

                              Post a Comment

                              Newer Post Older Post Home
                              Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

                              Blog Archive

                              • ►  2021 (32)
                                • ►  April (2)
                                • ►  March (8)
                                • ►  February (8)
                                • ►  January (14)
                              • ►  2020 (149)
                                • ►  December (17)
                                • ►  November (12)
                                • ►  October (12)
                                • ►  September (11)
                                • ►  August (12)
                                • ►  July (12)
                                • ►  June (16)
                                • ►  May (17)
                                • ►  April (15)
                                • ►  March (14)
                                • ►  February (6)
                                • ►  January (5)
                              • ►  2019 (94)
                                • ►  December (8)
                                • ►  November (11)
                                • ►  October (6)
                                • ►  September (9)
                                • ►  August (5)
                                • ►  July (8)
                                • ►  June (5)
                                • ►  May (10)
                                • ►  April (14)
                                • ►  March (6)
                                • ►  February (4)
                                • ►  January (8)
                              • ►  2018 (96)
                                • ►  December (13)
                                • ►  November (4)
                                • ►  October (10)
                                • ►  September (8)
                                • ►  August (6)
                                • ►  July (10)
                                • ►  June (8)
                                • ►  May (4)
                                • ►  April (8)
                                • ►  March (9)
                                • ►  February (7)
                                • ►  January (9)
                              • ▼  2017 (102)
                                • ►  December (8)
                                • ►  November (6)
                                • ►  October (9)
                                • ►  September (8)
                                • ►  August (5)
                                • ►  July (11)
                                • ►  June (9)
                                • ►  May (11)
                                • ▼  April (15)
                                  • Trump’s Russian friend: associate of New York’s to...
                                  • Mugwumps of the World, Unite!
                                  • Chernobyl catastrophe consequences create huge rad...
                                  • Labour commitment to fire Trident is sheer madness
                                  • Conservatives' nuclear WMD first strike threat hi...
                                  • Nuclear weapons are increasingly just too risky fo...
                                  • Putting the MOAB big bang in a nuclear context
                                  • Labour's big nuclear disarmament election opportu...
                                  • Remembering the man who alerted the world to the n...
                                  • Why it is just so darned hard to establish the pro...
                                  • US' s giant chemical weapons complex in Washington...
                                  • Chemical weapons: the good, bad and the ugly- how ...
                                  • Truth and alternative truth over Nazis and Zionism...
                                  • Saudi Arabia's medievalist Kingdom's atomic ambitions
                                  • Nuclear fallout from any attack on North Korea
                                • ►  March (9)
                                • ►  February (3)
                                • ►  January (8)
                              • ►  2016 (105)
                                • ►  December (6)
                                • ►  November (9)
                                • ►  October (6)
                                • ►  September (7)
                                • ►  August (9)
                                • ►  July (19)
                                • ►  June (8)
                                • ►  May (6)
                                • ►  April (10)
                                • ►  March (11)
                                • ►  February (2)
                                • ►  January (12)
                              • ►  2015 (125)
                                • ►  December (16)
                                • ►  November (14)
                                • ►  October (12)
                                • ►  September (6)
                                • ►  August (10)
                                • ►  July (12)
                                • ►  June (11)
                                • ►  May (9)
                                • ►  April (8)
                                • ►  March (5)
                                • ►  February (10)
                                • ►  January (12)
                              • ►  2014 (66)
                                • ►  December (7)
                                • ►  November (5)
                                • ►  October (2)
                                • ►  September (1)
                                • ►  August (7)
                                • ►  July (6)
                                • ►  June (5)
                                • ►  May (5)
                                • ►  April (6)
                                • ►  March (7)
                                • ►  February (7)
                                • ►  January (8)
                              • ►  2013 (57)
                                • ►  December (8)
                                • ►  November (5)
                                • ►  October (6)
                                • ►  September (10)
                                • ►  August (4)
                                • ►  July (5)
                                • ►  June (9)
                                • ►  May (7)
                                • ►  April (3)

                              About Me

                              My photo
                              drdavidlowry
                              View my complete profile
                              Simple theme. Powered by Blogger.